Tue 8 Jul 2008
I hope everyone had a great 4th of July weekend. I personally spent some time at “the Beach”, though not actually at the beach. The weather was not cooperative, and to be quite truthful I’m not much of a beach person. I like going to beaches in far away and “exotic” locales, but don’t like going to the beach just to go to the beach.
Everytime, I go away for the weekend within driving distance, I wonder if having a summer or winter home makes sense. Would I use it? Would it be a good investment? I have only mulled the question without really coming up with an answer.
Would I use it?
This is the most important question. While making a great investment is all good and dandy, the real reason to own a place is to enjoy it’s use. Living in boston I’m within two hours of both the mountains and the beach. I firmly believe that if it takes more than 4 hours to get “there,” it’s not worth it. Both summer beach homes and winter ski lodges are really only useful 3 to 4 months of the year. The question is, would I use it enough to make it worthwhile? Given my current habits, I know I wouldn’t. However, I can envision changing my habits. I would have to go on fewer long vacations and replace them with shorter trips to the vacation home.
Is it a worthwhile Investment?
The question of evaluating a property as investment is much more straightforward, or at least on the surface. But really the question can’t be fully answered without also taking into account the personal benefits. Vacation homes are rarely good investments in themselves, but can be a fantastic investment when they also provide weekends spent with family and friends. With the housing market in turmoil, this might be a great time to get a great deal on a place, or not.
The one area that Vacation homes can provide unique benefits is in the area of taxation. The IRS provides a great deal of flexibility on how a vacation home is treated depending on how much it gets used as personal property or as rental property. While I have my own personal reservations on why the Government should be giving tax breaks on mortgage interest, let alone second home mortgage interest, I can hardly argue against anyone for taking advantage of the rules as they are.
A Home on the Cape:
For example a 2 bedroom home on the Cape near the beach would cost me about 300-380kk. If I were able to put down the full 20% down of a 320k home that would leave me with a mortgage of about 256k and monthly payments of $1620 a month (assuming a 30 year term and 6.5% rate) or about a little over 19,000 a year, and more like $21,000 after considering property taxes. A realistic scenario would allow me to rent out the unit for 8 weeks of the year for $1000 a week. Renting it out for about 8 weeks would then leave me with 2 “prime” summer weeks, and another 4 weeks slightly out of season. Without considering the tax consequences or other complexities; the question is $13,000 worth 6 weeks of a vacation home? I could spend $13,000 and have a fantastic 4 week exotic vacation for my girlfriend and I.
The last part is the rub really. A vacation home is much more worthwhile when you have a family to share it with. Being unmarried and without children that benefit is greatly diminished. Without expectations of inflated real estate returns, the economics do not make sense. A vacation home is best used when more people are able to take advantage of it. That’s why, I’ve actually never seriously considered purchasing a vacation home on my own. I would much rather go into such an endeavor with either family or friends at this stage in my life.

