Fri 7 Mar 2008
I’ve commented in the past how some personal finance bloggers can across smug. However, given the audience, this smugness is not a big deal. The fact is the writers of personal finance blogs reflect the attitudes of the readers. I’m both a writer and reader, and I can personally attest to the fact that I probably too often fall victim to a “holier than thou” attitude. This isn’t really a problem in the blogsphere where we cavort amongst ourselves. The greater problem is in the real world. Despite, my self effacing shell, I am rather self satisfied.However, I do feel very strongly about spreading the wisdom of prudent finances. A “I know better than you” attitude often gets in the way of that. Nobody wants to listen to a know it all. I certainly don’t. I think if we are to give advice to family and friends, we should first admit our own financial shortcomings. I know some of mine are:
1) I’m less careful than I should be - I get more parking tickets, and other fines than I should
2) I spend alot of money of food and vacations
3) I enjoy expensive hobbies like skiing and golf
Telling somone that every life choice that they make is wrong isn’t a way to gain influence and win friends. We shouldn’t be telling people what they’re doing wrong, but rather working with them on doing things better. Criticicsm is healthly, but in small manageable chunks.
Just as important as being able to impart wisdom upon friends is also keeping an open mind for oneself. Just because your plan works today doesn’t mean it’ll work tomorrow. I find it useful to get off my high horse at least on occasion and revevaluate some of my beliefs. It’s the only way to keep on learning. For example, I used to be much more dismissive of commodity investing than I am today. I realize in the current market there’s really nothing else like commodities as much as I wish there were.
If you enjoyed this post, please subscribe to the RSS feed
March 7th, 2008 at 6:30 pm
My financial shortfalls:
Shopping for clothes (yes, this includes the bikinis I just bought), beauty products (I’m a product junkie) and gifts (I like to spend money on other people).
Recreation-I have a Lemond (yeah, it’s an expensive bike). I rock climb (gyms are expensive). I take tennis lessons (not cheap, but I’m getting better).
Eating out–I’m lazy. I also am a horrible cook. Combine the two and take-out is a miracle.
March 7th, 2008 at 8:51 pm
Yeah, I think that PF bloggers can get snobby about their point of views. I try not to be that way because personal finance is well, personal. There are some rules of thumbs that just make common sense (like getting out of high interest debt), but past that those, it’s really up to the individual. Everyone has shortfalls and strengths.
Btw, I wholeheartedly agree with the post you linked to regarding luck vs. hard work.
March 10th, 2008 at 2:14 am
I agree about the need for humility, it’s pretty necessary in all endeavours in life I think. For me, the best PF blogs (or any advice blogs really) are those that encourage me to think about my own values and to align what I do with what I believe. If you value the experience of golfing and skiing, and find it really does good things for you, then it’s not a ‘bad’ use of money unless it conflicts with some other value you have. I’m with SavingDiva - takeout is not an “unnecessary expense” when it’s the only thing between you and starvation!
March 10th, 2008 at 9:57 pm
I had somehow missed your earlier post about the smug comment. Granted, making $100K+ most assuredly creates a better opportunity to fund things like a 401(k), Roth IRA, etc. HOWEVER, it is not done so easily that compromises and trade-offs are not made elsewhere…particularly if that income is for the entire family.
Admittedly, when it comes to others’ finances, I find myself willing to admonish those who continue to “fall off the wagon” or make choices that are contradictory to their stated goals (ex: getting rid of their debt). I think this is both partly because I see too many “hugs” given on pf blogs as well as my own strong desire to see them succeed (tough love?).