Mon 25 Jun 2007
One of the toughest things to do when starting to invest in picking which mutual funds to invest in, even when you’ve wedded yourself to mostly tracking the indexes. There are many different indexes, and there are many different funds that track these indexes. Then you have to decide if you want an exchange traded fund (ETF) which you can buy and sell during the day like a stock or a plain old vanilla mutual fund. The paralysis that comes from making these decision can often be much more costly than choosing one fund versus another. Generally speaking the most important part of investing is to be invested. Letting a IRA account sit in cash for years does no good.
So what should you invest in? I don’t have any firm answers, but below are some index funds that I’ve either personally invested in or taken some time to look at.
The best known indexes of the U.S. Stock Market are the Dow Jones Industrial Average, the S&P 500, Wilshire 5000, and the Russell 2000, but there are many other indexes. Most indexes segment U.S. companies by size as measured by market capitilization. For example the S&P 500 index is suppose to the be 500 largest companies in the U.S. (in actuality it’s somewhat different). The Rusell 2000 on the other hand is index of small companies. Private companies, Standard and Poor in the case of the S&P 500, maintain the composition of the index by choosing which companies are added or removed from the index. Some indexes are sector indexes, for instances the Dow Jones Transportation Index tracks transportation companies. Most indexes, the exception being the Dow Jow Industrial Average, are weighted by market capitalization to give greater relevance to bigger companies. For example if I had an index consisting of only two stocks, A and B. Company A is 4 times as large as B, my index would be 4 times more sentitive to the price movement in stock A in comparison to stock B. The Dow Jones on the other hand does not differentiate companies by size, and as result if I constructed an index using it’s price weighted methodology that index would be equally sentitive to price movements in stock A or B.
Below are a list of some funds. I’ve highlighted in yellow funds that I personally own. When it comes to indexe funds, it’s really all about cost. Choose the lowest cost fund for you. This is measured not only management fees but potential trading costs. For instance, I own WFIVX because at my brokerage, E*Trade, I can buy and sell it for free and the company rebates the 12-1b fees. I would incur a transaction cost if I did the same thing with a Vanguard fund. However if you use Vanguard then you would probably have the opposite problem.
| Index/Fund Description | Fund Name | Fund Symbol | ETF Fund | ETF Symbol |
| Total Market Index, Wilshire 5000 | Vanguard Total Market Index Fund | VTSMX | Vangurad Total Market ETF | VTI |
| Fidelity Spartan Total Market Index Fund | FSTMX | |||
| T. Rowe Price Total Market Index Fund | POIMX | |||
| Wishire 5000 Index Fund | WFIVX | |||
| S&P 500 Index | Vangaurd S&P 500 Fund | VFINX | SPDR S&P 500 ETF | SPY |
| Fidelity Spartan 500 Fund | FSMKX | |||
| Schwab S&P 500 Index | SWPIX | |||
| Russell 2000 Index | Vanguard Small Cap Index | NAESX | iShares Russell 2000 Value Index | IWN |
| E*TRADE Russell 2000 Index | ETRUX |
I believe a critical part of anyone’s portfolio should be exposure to foreign stocks, especially if you’re young. Foreign investing is a much trickier beast than domestic investing. Along with a diverse set regional, and country indexes, foreign funds can also be further broken to mature vs. emerging markets. Brazil, Russian, India and China (often collectively known as BRIC) are considered emerging market, while western Europe is a mature market. There is also the distinction to be made between foreign and international. Internatioanl funds contain U.S. companies, while foreign funds exclude U.S. Companies. The best known and mostly widely used indexes are the MSCI (Morgan Stanley Capital International) and FTSE (Financial Times and London Stock Exchange) Indexes. Morgan Stanley maintains a wide range country/regional and sector indexes while FTSE tends to specialize in larger, broader indexes. However, finding quality traditional mutual funds that track them all is not so easy. Barclay iShares offers a wide set of MSCI and FTSE ETFs (a few which I’ve listed here).
| Index/Fund Description | Fund Name | Fund Symbol | ETF Fund | ETF Symbol |
| FTSE All-World ex US Index | Vanguard FTSE All-World ex-US Index Inv | VFWIX | Vanguard FTSE All-World ex-US ETF | VEU |
| Vanguard International Stock Index Fund. International Fund. Holds underlying Vanguard European, Pacific, and Emeerging Market Vanguard Funds |
VGTSX | |||
| MSCI Emerging Markets Index | Vanguard Emerging Market Fund | VEIEX | iShares MSCI Emerg Mkts Fund | EEM |
| MSCI Brazil Markets Index | iShares MSCI Brazil | EWZ | ||
| MSCI Japan Markets Index | iShares MSCI Japan | EWJ | ||
| FTSE Xinhua China 25 Index | iShares Xinhua China 25 | FXI | ||
| Actively Managed | Dodge & Cox Internation Fund | DOFX |
As you can see I’ve also included DODFX which is an actively managed mutual fund. I own the fund and think highly of it’s managment style, and Dodge & Cox ability to deliver consistently excellent returns while still keeping expenses relatively low. If there’s one place to have an actively managed fund, it’s foreign given the increased complications that come with following multiple countries.
If you enjoyed this post, please subscribe to the RSS feed
December 21st, 2007 at 8:14 pm
Up until a few years I struggled with the idea of picking funds. After a short time, some did well & others not so well. Then I gained access to Financial Engines and thought I was on to something, but the problem is that each time I ran an analysis, the results were different (i.e., chasing a moving target). Then one day, I stumbled onto http://www.fundadvice.com and have never looked back. Paul Merriman has a fantastic website with tons of information and all of it is free. My portfolio is based on his Vanguard suggesed buy-and-hold portfolio but includes some asset classes that he hints at adding elsewhere (i.e., in his blog), but not in the actual suggested portfolio. In it’s simplist form it goes like this:
Equities:
(1) 50/50 US/International split
(2) 50/50 Large/Small Cap split (of above)
(3) 50/50 Value/Blend (of above)
The problem is that at Vanguard, you cannot obtain the International Small Cap or International Small Cap Value asset classes unless you substitute with something else. I do this with two funds that I treat as one asset class:
(a) DLS 75%
(b) PISRX 25% (but can be as little as 10% or as much as 40%)
DLS is a very close proxy to the now closed Vangard International Explorer fund (VINEX). You can have your DLS dividends automatically reinvested (just ask Vanguard) for no cost. When you need to adjust the asset class (i.e., when you rebalance), you can buy/sell shares of PISRX (which is a NO-TRANSACTION-FEE, or NTF fund at Vanguard).
For the Bond side, I use:
50% Intermediate Term US Treasuries
30% Short Term US Treasuries
20% TIPS
And I have a cash position held in a Vanguard Prime MMF.
The key here is to adjust the overall ratio of equities/bonds/cash so that you can sleep at nights. This is going to be different for everyone, but the underlying funds can all be the same for everyone. In Wm Bernsteins book “The Four Pillars of Investing” he advocates holding a cash position that can be used when equities (stocks) go on sale (i.e., after a market correction). The Bond portion of the portfolio will hopefully prevent you from doing something silly in a market correction because it will limit your paper losses (provided that you are true long term buy-and-hold investor). And lastly, buying the funds at Vanguard keeps your costs very low & as John Bogle says over & over again… “Costs matter”
I’ve added a little more depth to my portfolio by extending the US Small Cap asset class with John Montogomery’s microcap BRSIX fund. I’ve also added some REITS (VGSIX) and REOCS (TRREX) to the portfolio (but they aren’t really necessary). Yes, they are great to use as an asset class, because they aren’t so correlated to the other asset classes, but in a well diversified portfolio they don’t add a whole lot of return. I constructed mine before Paul Merriman updated his buy-and-hold portfolio to include them as an asset class.
The nice thing about this portfolio is that it is very easy to sleep at night, and I rebalance 1-2 times per year. I am balanced across my Roth, Rollover, 401K, non-retirment, and my wife’s Roth & Rollover. Borrowing a page from Larry Swedroe, our Roths are entirely US Small Cap Value (the idea is to invest the asset class that has the most potential to make the most over a long period of time in a Roth). In other words, the location decision (where you put certain asset classes also matters). We are at a point where we’ll have to start adding another asset class in our Roth & that will be US Large Value or International Large Value.
The largest problem is that I have a poor choice of investments in my 401K, but use DODGX, NOSIX, & DFSTX as the core of three asset classes. The 4th is an intermediate Term bond fund that is okay. I wish we had access to VGTSX or VTRIX in our 401K (or any international but we don’t).
I am always interested in what others do & how they fare with it. This is a cool website. Kudo’s to dong.